If you take a large group of people, at a Premier League football match say, I would be willing to bet a not insignificant sum of money that the number of people among them who have ever ordered a McDonald’s ‘Filet O’Fish’ can be counted on one hand. It’s the thing on the menu that no one orders. Why would they? If you are the kind of person that orders fish, you are ergo not the kind of person typically to go to McDonald’s. I have images of hardened employees slaving away in the backrooms of a McDonald’s eatery, when suddenly an alarm goes off. Everyone’s heads rise in unison. Some of the younger employees are frightened. The older employees recall, from deep within the recesses of their memories, that such a signal means only one thing: someone has to forage in the back of the freezer for the frozen fish slabs, for Lo! the Filet O’Fish has been ordered. Today is a very special day.
Up until very recently, I would have counted myself among the vast hordes of humanity for whom the Filet O’Fish is nothing more than an esoteric idea. However, circumstances recently conspired to place me in a branch of McDonald’s, in Finchley, with a Filet O’Fish and a salad before me. Let’s retrace the steps that lead me to this point.
The first thing to note is that I tend to be rather broke throughout the month of August. Believe it or not I do not get paid for my endeavours with this here blog; I have to rely on a day job. My day job primarily involves working in schools, which are not typically open during August. So I have no income stream throughout this month, and I have to have my wits about me. I have to open my mind to culinary opportunities I might otherwise not consider.
The second step on my path to the aforementioned McDonald’s eatery involved a leaflet that was posted through my door one Tuesday morning. The leaflet consisted of a set of detachable vouchers, each of which entitled the bearer to a meal in McDonald’s for the sum of £1.99. Now I am very far from a fan of McDonald’s, but that seemed like a pretty good deal. My local McDonald’s is about a mile away, so were I to walk there, and to include a salad rather than chips as part of my meal, I would be racking up a decent bit of exercise too. I made up my mind that, the next day, I would partake of my luncheon at McDonald’s.
The third thing to note is that, when it comes to McDonald’s, my options are somewhat curtailed. For, you see, I do not eateth of the meateth. Therefore, I was limited in my choice to a veggie burger or a Filet O’Fish (I eat fish but not meat. I am incoherent in my moral system). I decided against the veggie burger for two reasons. The first was that, in all likelihood, it would not be very good. I am quite frankly sick of bean-based veggie burgers. Were it a Quorn-burger, or similar, I would be all over it like an [insert witty simile here], but I knew it wouldn’t be. It would be the typical patty of joylessness that counts as a veggie burger in most fast-food outlets. The second reason was that this was a perfect opportunity, given all the aforementioned factors, to do what very few before me have ever done, and to order the lesser-spotted Filet O’Fish. I was to be an entrepreneur, a visionary, a pioneer and an explorer all rolled into one human shaped ball of flesh.
So that’s what I did. I presented my order to the slack-jawed, uncomprehending lady behind the counter, waited the obligatory ten minutes whilst the frozen fish slab was unearthed at the behest of the alarm, then sauntered off to a boothette, notebook in hand, to partake of my purchase.
In a way it is a shame that the Filet O’Fish is so perennially underlooked, for it is in essence a highly passable fish finger sandwich. Since I ordered a salad in lieu of fries I was able to add some much needed greenery to the burger. The tartare sauce is decent and not unlike Big Mac sauce, and contains bits of onion and gherkin which imparts a pleasing tang. The bun is squishy and tasty, and slightly sweet in a brioche-like kind of way, and the whole shebang comes with half a piece of cheese. That’s right – cheese. In no other context would I ever expect cheese to be served with fish, but in this case the combo works. In fact, it works so well that it is a mystery to me why it is only half a piece. The internet informs me, however, that this is standard practice with the Filet O’Fish – half a slice of cheese. It’s as though McDonald’s have half acknowledge that the addition of cheese to fish is pretty fucking weird, but decided they wanted to give it a go anyway. So all in all, the Filet O’Fish is well worth £1.99.
Now, I just mentioned buns and cheese. I wish to end this essay with a coda, if you will, and say something about the role of buns and cheese in McDonald’s food more generally. It is undeniably the case that, whatever one’s gustatory pretentions, McDonald’s food tends to taste quite good. There is not an obesity crisis for no reason, after all. I venture to suggest that the buns and cheese they use are heavily contributory factors in the eatability of McDonalds’ fare. I’ve no idea what they put in it – crack or something, probably. As a kind of thought experiment, imagine eating a Big Mac with no cheese, and in a Kingsmill bun. It’s a bit shit, isn’t it? That’s science, that is.
Fillet O’Fish: 7/10